Protacanthamoeba
Protacanthamoeba Page, 1981 (ref. ID; 3991 original paper, 7710)
Order Acanthopodida Page, 1976 (ref. ID; 6789)
[ref. ID; 3991]
Slender, flexible, sometimes furcate subpseudopodia, produced from a broad, hyaline lobopodium; centrospheres including plaque-shaped centriole-like body; cyst without preformed pores or opercula. (ref. ID; 3991)
Comments; Protacanthamoeba n. g. is undoubtedly a member of the family Acanthamoebidae (Sawyer & Griffin 1975) by virtue of the light- and electron-microscopical characters of its trophozoites. The distinction between Acanthamoebidae and Echinamoebidae on the basis of presence or absence of performed pores and opercula in the cyst (Page 1976) cannot be maintained. The families Acanthamoebidae and Echinamoebidae were proposed almost simultaneously (Page 1975; Sawyer & Griffin 1975) without the authors of each being aware of the other new family before publication. The argument of Pernin & Pussard (1979) that a better distinction is necessary is accepted, but no better distinction was available at the time when the two families were established. However, it is obvious that some members of the Echinamoebidae as originally defined are very different from Acanthamoebidae, and a re-definition of the families must be postponed until the genera now classified as Echinamoebidae can be investigated with the electron microscope. Furthermore, the differences between the active stage of Comandonia on the one hand and Acanthamoeba and Protacanthamoeba on the other raise a question about the familial affinities of Comandonia. (ref. ID; 3991)
Type species; Protacanthamoeba caledonica (ref. ID; 3991)
- Protacanthamoeba caledonica Page, 1981 (ref. ID; 3991 original paper)
- Protacanthamoeba invadens (Singh & Hanumaiah, 1979) n. comb. (ref. ID; 3991)
Diagnosis
Amoebae in locomotion mostly 20-40 um, with length greater than or occasionally equal to width; sometimes with long drawn-out (spatulate) posterior end; subpseudopodia up to 8 um long, commonly about 3.5 um; mean diameter of rounded cells approximately 19 um; mean nuclear diameter approximately 8 um. Cysts usually smooth-walled to light microscope; cyst wall three-layered, with fine structure of outer wall fibrillar, middle layer dense, inner layer finely granular; layers usually in close contact, but tangential splitting often giving rise to pseudo-exocyst; thickness of cyst approximately 0.6 times greatest diameter. Original strain does not grown at 37 degrees C. (ref. ID; 3991)
Descriptions
- Light microscopy: In the locomotive form these amoebae are indistinguishable from Acanthamoeba, though they occasionally have, either on a glass substratum or agar a drawn-out posterior region, unusual in Acanthamoeba. Acanthopodia, up to 8 um long, are produced from the dorsal surface or front edge of the hyaline lobopodium and carried back along the sides as the amoeba advances, sometimes contributing to a group of uroidal filaments. The lengths of 100 amoebae, including few with a drawn-out posterior end, were 13.9-60.0 um, mostly less than 40 um, with a mean of 26.7 um, and their length/width ratios 1.0-3.6 (mean 1.6). The locomotive rates of 10 amoebae at 22 degrees C were 4.6-13.9 um, or 0.2-0.4 times their lengths, per min. The nucleus has a single central nucleolus. Diameters of 25 nuclei in live amoebae were 7.0-9.2 um (mean 8.3 um), with their nucleoli 3.8-6.2 um (mean 5.3 um). In stained preparations, diameters (n=25) were: nuclei 4.7-8.4 um (mean 6.3 um), nucleoli, 2.6-4.7 um (mean 3.5 um). In each set, a few nuclei were somewhat elongate. Occasional binucleate cells were seen in stained preparations made from one-day-old cultures. The cytoplasm often contained many spherical, yellowish bodies about 1 um in diameter or less, which took up Sudan black stain. The floating form, produced when amoebae were suspended in liquid, was more or less rounded, with acanthopodia whose length often nearly equaled the diameter of the central mass. The diameters of the central cell masses of 70 floating forms, measured in three groups at different times, were 12-26 um, with means of 18.1 um, 19.2 um, and 20.4 um for the three groups. No detailed study of mitosis was made, but the nucleolus disappeared during mitosis, and a rather conspicuous spindle remnant like than figured by Singh (1952) for Hartmannella glebae was often seen in telophase, persisting even when cytokinesis was far advanced. The cysts sometimes occurs singly, usually in groups, even in plaques of hundred closely appressed and adherent to each other. They were usually circular to oval in outline, rarely slightly reniform because of pressure on one side. The wall was usually smooth, even when two layers were distinguishable, but there was often a slight separation in the wall at some points, with slight wrinkling of the separated outer part. Rarely the separation extended around all or most of the periphery. No ostioles, as seen in many Acanthamoeba, were found, no opercula, present in all Acanthamoeba though difficult to perceive in the intact cysts of a few species, were observed. Nor was there a regular peripheral layer of coarse cytoplasmic granules as commonly seen in Acanthamoeba. The cysts were uninucleate; in a few, as sometimes in Acanthamoeba, the nucleolar material appeared to be separated into two bodies. Measurements of 100 cysts on each of three separate occasions gave diameters (the greatest for each cyst) of 11-21 um, with means on the three occasions of 16.0 um, 16.7 um, and 16.8 um. Twenty-five cysts were measured to establish the ratio of the thickness (vertical diameter) to the greatest horizontal diameter, giving: greatest diameter, 13.1-20 um (mean 16.4 um); thickness, 8-11 um (mean 10 um); ratio of thickness:greatest diameter, 0.5-0.7 (mean 0.6). These cysts were therefore thickly lenticular. In 25 living cysts, the nuclear diameters were 4.7-6.5 um (mean 5.8 um), the nucleoli 1.9-3.7 um (mean 2.8 um). Reduction in size of nuclei and relative size of nucleoli during encystment has been observed in many amoebae. (ref. ID; 3991)
- Electron microscopy: A longitudinal section of a locomotive form shows a little anterior hyaloplasm and the small posterior hyaloplasmic region, which, with the uroidal filaments when these are present, makes up the uroid. A section of a lobopodium with some of the acanthopodia produced from it contained tracts of oriented filaments extending from deep in the lobopodium into the acanthopodia, with masses of less oriented material between the filament tracts. This presence of non-oriented material between the filamentous tracts accords with the suggested "tent-pole" function of acanthopodia, although it does not prove that hypothesis. The filaments appeared to extend the length of acanthopodia, resembling observations on acanthopodia of Acanthamoeba castellanii and elongated sub-pseudopodia of other genera. Some remnants of this internal structure could be discerned in some of the uroidal filaments derived from acanthopodia. The nuclear envelope was ca. 30-40 nm thick, with many nucleopores, but the outer surface was not covered with ribosomes. Although the nucleoli of some cells appeared fairly dense, usually with lighter lacunae, they were often less dense and markedly heterogeneous. Mitochondria were mostly oval to sausage-shaped in section, with a maximum length somewhat over 2 um. Anastomosing of tubular cristae was observed less frequently than in some amoebae, and intracristal granules were present. The matrix of mitochondria fixed for an hour at 20 degrees was consistently dense than that in cell fixed by other methods. The Golgi region was prominent and extensive (up to 4.2 um across, usually somewhat less) and often contained two or more stacks of flattened sacs, transverse and longitudinal sections of membranous tubules, and vesicles up to 0.3 um in diameter. Whenever both Golgi apparatus and nucleus were present in the same section, they were close together. Often two Golgi areas were seen in a cell, suggesting that that is the normal number. Centriole-like bodies identical in structure to those found in several species of Acanthamoeba were seen in material treated with glutaraldehyde at 20 degrees C, always in association with the Golgi apparatus. The centriole-like body consisted of amorphous-looking electron-dense outer layers each ca. 30 nm thick, and, sandwiched between them, two rows of circular structures described by Willaert, Stevens & Tyndall (1978) as "resembling beads on a string", this inner region being ca. 60 nm thick. The way in which the centriole-like body seemed to fade away at either end suggested that it is a circular plaque, and both the appearance and the size of the two rows of circular structures sandwiched between the amorphous layers suggested that these might be sections of microtubules like those radiating out from the centriole-like body. In at least one cell, two such bodies, each in a separated Golgi region, were observed; unfortunately, the nucleus was not present in these sections. Microtubules were sometimes seen passing through Golgi regions in which no centriole-like bodies were seen, and there were a few configurations suggesting such bodies even in cells fixed by methods other than the optimal one. The rough endoplasmic reticulum, in the form of flattened lengths, was not abundant in trophic cells; the smooth endoplasmic reticulum appeared to take type same form, though a few open vesicles were also present. The contractile vacuole, several stages of which were seen, appeared to belong to Patterson's morphological type D, though with the vesicles of the spongiome so numerous in early diastole that it somewhat resembled his type C. Food vacuoles with the ingested organisms still intact usually appeared to contain on one bacterium each. Several morphological changes characterized encysting cells even in early stages with the contractile vacuole still functioning. Such cells were well rounded up, generally somewhat oval in section, with the entire surface having a rippled appearance, probably from the exocytotic activity of many small vesicles bringing wall material to the surface. The first wall layer laid down was made up of fibrous material, with the fibers running parallel to the cell surface as a whole but not following the numerous exocytotic depression, though some material in those depressions appeared to be of the same texture. The cytoplasm was denser than that of trophic amoebae, and rough endoplasmic reticulum was often abundant. The most conspicuous inclusions were ovoid or spherical membrane-bound bodies, their greatest diameter up to 3 um but usually somewhat smaller. The dense contents of these bodies sometimes appeared to be amorphous, but were often seen to be in large part crystalline arrangements of spherules each measuring about 25 nm. There can be little doubt that these are the "ribonucleo-protein-containing vesicles" identified by Schuster & Svihla (1968) in their study of Naegleria gruberi as "autophagosomal-like vacuoles" and by Bowers & Korn (1969) and Willaert, Stevens & Tyndall (1978) as autolysosomes in Acanthamoeba. The contents of these vesicles were complex and included polysaccharides, as shown by Thiery preparations. Large numbers of lipid bodies were present in encysting cells. The mature cyst wall was ca. 0.3 um thick, excluding material in the surface depressions, where not split. It could be divided into three principal regions, from the outside: (1) fibrous, with fibers parallel to the surface, shown not only by its position but also by its textural resemblance to be identical with the material first secreted; (2) dense, apparently amorphous but with a suggestion that it may be composed of tightly-packed bodies; (3) finely granular, less dense but thicker than either of the preceding. Splitting frequently occurred within the fibrous outer layer and between the outer and middle layer, giving rise in light-microscopical observations to the deceptive appearance of a true exocyst and endocyst. The innermost of the three principal regions was usually subdivided by one or two trilaminar boundaries, the inner one of which might not continue around the entire periphery. Furthermore, the material closest to the cell membrane and in the depressions of the cell surface appeared slightly darker than the rest of the inner region, which may thus be divided into three or four strata, all consisting of morphologically similar material. This inner region was less densely stained by the Thiery treatment than are the two outer ones. (ref. ID; 3991)
Comments
This strain appears to belong to the same species as organisms designated Hartmannella glebae by Singh (1952), since when other authors (e.g., Sawyer & Griffin 1975) have used the specific epithet in the same sense, that is, Acanthamoeba-like organism with a cyst lacking any preformed route of exit. However, comparison of Dobell's (1914) description of his Amoeba glebae with the descriptions by Singh (1952) and Singh & Das (1970) raises strong doubts about the use of Dobell's specific epithet by the latter authors. One reasons for doubt is Dobell's description of a "banded appearance when seen in optical section" of the outer later of the cyst wall. There are also size differences. Although Dobell gave the species of "rounded" amoebae as 12-20 um, he said that the average size of "spherical organisms' during nuclear division was 16-17 um. Singh & Das (1970) reported the diameter of the rounded form as 15-30 um. The cyst diameters are less easily reconcilable. Dobell gave this as 10 um to a little more than 13 um. Singh & Das did not reported cyst diameter, but their illustrations yield figures of 15-19.4 um. Cyst diameters of the Scottish strain in the present study were 11-21 um, with a mean of 16.5 um for 300 cysts. To attribute the size difference between Dobell's findings and their own to "unsuitable cultural conditions" in Dobell's study, as Singh & Das (1970) did, is unwarranted and unhelpful. The variation might to due to differences in food supply or age of culture but could also be due to either intraspecific variations or misidentification by the latter authors. Differences between the accounts of Dobell and the later workers included details of the mitotic figure, though differences in the shape of that figure do not appear reliable enough for taxonomic use. It seems unlikely, therefore, and certainly at least questionable, that the organism studied by later workers belong to Dobell's species. It is possible that the Scottish isolate described in the present study belong to the same species as the organism investigated under the names Hartmannella glebae and Acanthamoeba glebae by Singh and co-workers. Dobell's name cannot be used for any of these. The most similar genus is Acanthamoeba Volkonsky, 1931, as amended by Page (1967), in which the organism that Singh called Hartmannella glebae has been included by recent authors (Sawyer & Griffin 1975; Singh & Hanumaiah 1979). The trophic amoeba of P. caledonica is indistinguishable from that of Acanthamoeba with the light microscope. This similarity extends to the electron-microscopical level, most strikingly in the possession of a centriole-like body, which with the associated Golgi apparatus constitutes the centrosphere of Pussard & Pons (1978). The cysts wall differs, of course, in its lack of performed pores closed by opercula. It can be seen that the exocyst or outer layer of the Acanthamoeba cyst wall consists of fibrillar material oriented parallel to the cell surface, facilitating splitting. The endocyst is complex: an outer layer of sparse, finely fibrous material not always oriented in the same direction; a denser middle layer which at the ostioles (bordering on the opercula) appears continuous with the exocyst; and an inner region which appears finely granules, but on closer examination can be seen at least in places to consist of the fine fibrils tangential to the cell surface. It appears that the outermost layer of the endocyst is simply material that has been torn and somewhat disoriented by separation of exocyst and endocyst during continued dehydration of the cell after hardening other exocyst. The cyst wall of A. polyphaga therefore consists of only two morphologically distinguishable materials: that making up the exocyst and the sparse (therefore lightly stained) two outer layers of the endocyst, and that making up the more finely fibrillar, though granular-appearing, inner layer of the endocyst. In contrast, there appear to be three morphological distinct regions in the cyst wall of Protacanthamoeba. Cysts of other species of Acanthamoeba have been described from electron-microscopical observations. The negative zinc chloroiodide test on the cysts of P. caledonica is not advanced as conclusive evidence that cellulose is lacking. The question can be settled only by analysis. The observation and explanation of pseudo-exocyst formation in P. caledonica emphasize the need for caution in interpreting light-microscopical observations of cysts which appears sometimes to have a single wall, sometimes two wall layers. Unpublished electron-micrographs of Hartmannella vermiformis Page, 1967, show a wall consisting entirely of a single material, which may split off near its external surface giving rise to the irregular pseudo-exocyst seen in some but not all cells (Page 1967), a description which Singh & Hanumaiah (1979) found "most confusing and inconsistent." Pernin & Pussard (1979) have described Comandonia operculata, which has a cyst with opercula to which the exocyst does not contribute a part as it does in Acanthamoeba. Furthermore, the trophic amoeba differs from both Acanthamoeba and Protacanthamoeba in several ways; type of subpseudopodia, presence of 10 or more contractile vacuoles, lack of classical dictyosome structure of Golgi apparatus, and lack of centriole-like body. (ref. ID; 3991)
Habitat
Isolated from estuary but probably present there only as cysts; probably occurring in fresh water and soil. (ref. ID; 3991)
Type materials
Type slides deposited in British Museum (Natural History). Holotype 1980:12:22:1. Paratype 1980:12:22:2. (ref. ID; 3991)